You're viewing an article in iPO's historic archive vault. Here, we've preserved the comments and how the site looked along with the article. Use this link to view the article on our current site: iTrip with LCD

Review

Review - iTrip with LCD

Looking to breathe new life into what was the first iPod-specific FM transmitter, Griffin Technology updated its iTrip earlier this summer, adding a display and external station control. Gone—at last—was the cumbersome process of selecting the station by playing a short audio clip, a major annoyance among fans of the iPod's Shuffle Songs feature.

Griffin iTrip with LCD
Griffin Technology iTrip with LCD

The iTrip with LCD features a similar design to its predecessors, being just as wide as a full-size iPod and only a little thicker. New to the LCD model is a chrome knob for tuning the FM frequency of choice, a very nice design touch even if the knob's turning action feels a little cheap.

Apart from being able to quickly tune in any frequency from 88.1MHz to 107.9MHz, the iTrip with LCD also features new LX and DX broadcasting modes. LX serves up your normal stereo transmission, while the more powerful DX mode delivers only mono audio. Griffin heralds the DX mode as the choice for users in cities with crowded airwaves, as the signal is able to "punch through cleanly." In our testing the DX mode did offer a clearer signal on FM stations that had a good bit of interference, but listening to music in mono feels so 1950's. It's perfect for audiobooks and podcasts, however.

iTrip LCD and iTrip Dock
iTrip with LCD and iTrip with Dock Connector

The makers of FM transmitters like to advertise their solution as being superior to cassette tape adapters, but I've yet to encounter one that can even match the sound quality of my Sony cassette adapter, let alone surpass it. Granted, the cassette adapter's cable is a bit of a drag, but it ends up being a small price to pay for a superior listening experience. Even the iTrip's little extra features, like support for international frequencies and automatic volume control, can't make up for its mediocre audio quality.

If you plan on using the iTrip primarily in your car, Newer Technology's more affordable RoadTrip!+ (5 stars, October 2005) is a superior product, being both easier to use and capable of charging your iPod at the same time. Additionally, the RoadTrip!+ broadcasts at 87.9MHz, a frequency that's unused in virtually all parts of the U.S. and that therefore makes it one of the best to listen to. The iTrip, however, only goes as low as 88.1MHz.

iTrip with LCD and iTrip with Dock Connector

If you're looking for a stylish and portable way to broadcast your music to a radio, the iTrip with LCD is a decent solution. If you primarily intend to use it for automative purposes, you're better off investing in a cassette adapter if you have a deck or direct line-in connection if your stereo supports that. If not, then the RoadTrip!+ is still the one to get.

Correction: In International mode the iTrip can dial in from 76.0MHz to 90.0MHz, including 87.9MHz. While this raises the appeal of the iTrip for users in crowded cities, it doesn't negate the mediocre sound quality and thus our rating remains unchanged.

Just The Facts

iTrip with LCD from Griffin Technology

MSRP US$39.99 / Street Price: US$29.99.

Pros: good design, easy to adjust stations

Cons: mediocre sound quality

3 comments from the community.

You can post your own below.

+ show options

Your current settings, click to change: Sort Oldest First, Show Guest Posts, Hide Community Stats

A guest said: (hide)

Actually the iTrip does go tp 87.9. You must enable the international settings by following the instruction manual to use it.

Quote this post ↓

A guest said: (hide)

Indeed, the iTrip can tune below 87.9 -- my car radio goes down to 87.5 and the iTrip can tune both 87.7 and 87.5 -- a distinct plus in a crowded market like NY.

Quote this post ↓

gslusher said:

member since 13 Nov 2002 with 2088 posts, unranked, send him a message or view his profile

Cassette adaptors are of little use to many people with new cars, which don't have cassette decks, only CD decks. If you're traveling and renting a car, take an FM transmitter: it will work with all car radios.

I have hundreds of cassettes, all unusable with my 2004 Prius. I got a Sony Walkman tape player and a Belkin TuneCast II FM transmitter. My iPod is directly wired into the car's system with the iPod2Car adaptor. (It takes the place of the CD changer I don't have.)

To understand why many new cars have CD decks only, go to a record store and look at the selection of cassettes vs CDs. Cassettes are on the way out: they're almost dead, except for audiobooks, where it's possible to cram a lot more onto one tape by using very thin tape. They can get away with that because audiobooks are seldom shuffled back and forth and are usually listened to only once or twice. (Audiobooks designed for lending libraries use a sturdier tape and, thus, need more tapes for each book.)

Quote this post ↓

Post Your Comments

  Remember Me

Not a member? Register now. You can post comments without logging in, but they'll show up as a "guest" post.


Please enter the word exactly as you see it in the image above. Registered users aren't prompted for this. Having trouble reading the image get a new one.