You're viewing an article in iPO's historic archive vault. Here, we've preserved the comments and how the site looked along with the article. Use this link to view the article on our current site: iCarPlay Wireless Plus

Review

Review - iCarPlay Wireless Plus

Having gone through at least a dozen FM transmitters and been disappointed by most, I've learned a couple things along the way: first, no FM transmitter will ever sound as good as a quality cassette adapter or, of course, a direct line-in connection; second, FM transmitters that double as iPod chargers, and thus our powered by a vehicle's 12V plug, sound better than stand-alone FM transmitters. With that in mind I tackled Monster's newest iCarPlay Wireless Plus FM transmitter and walked away satisfied with what I found.

iCarPlay
Monster iCarPlay Wireless Plus

As far as FM transmitters go, the futuristic looking design of the iCarPlay Wireless Plus is quite attractive. The 12V plug is outfitted with 24k gold connectors—which are surely more for marketing than performance purposes— and the Monster logo glows red when connected, a nice alternative to the typical green LED. The controller supports three FM presets and can be adjusted between bright and dim modes for nighttime driving.

The iCarPlay Wireless Plus supports the typical frequency range of 88.1MHz to 107.9MHz. While this means that it can't take advantage of those virtually unused 87.x frequencies that are ideal for personal listening and that some car stereos can tune into, I was impressed by how cleanly the iCarPlay Wireless Plus could transmit to frequencies that were anything but open. Even in the crowded Dallas-Fort Worth metroplex it wasn't difficult to find a frequency that the iCarPlay Wireless Plus would be able to transmit to with only a barely audible level of static, if any.

iCarPlay

Audio quality, while good as far as FM transmitters are concerned and probably satisfactory to many listeners, is still far from perfect. Highs don't sound so sharp, bass is slightly muffled, and the overall tonality is on the flat side. But this is true for all FM transmitters, and Monster at least deserves some kudos for including a disclaimer informing purchasers that "no FM transmitter will ever sound like your favorite 50,000 Watt radio station."

Like most Monster products, the iCarPlay Wireless Plus won't be winning any value awards any time soon. Retail is pegged at $80, but you can find it for closer to $60 from many resellers, in line with the going rate today for more "premium" FM transmitters. That's still twice what Newer Technology's RoadTrip!+ (5 stars) will set you back, however. While the RoadTrip!+ is fixed to 87.9MHz and looks totally bland, it does an equally fine job of beaming tunes to your radio.

The Bottom Line

It's not cheap, but Monster's iCarPlay Wireless Plus FM transmitter is one of the best FM transmitters we have come across for automative purposes.

Just The Facts

iCarPlay Wireless Plus from Monster

MSRP US$79.95 / Street Price: US$59.99.

Pros: transmits one of the strongest signals we've seen, attractive design, good audio quality for an FM transmitter

Cons: can't transmit to 87.xMHz frequencies, audio quality is still impeded by FM transmitter limitations

6 comments from the community.

You can post your own below.

+ show options

Your current settings, click to change: Sort Oldest First, Show Guest Posts, Hide Community Stats

A guest said: (hide)

I have the previous model and it works quite well. If I crest a hill I may get some interference from a line of sight signal from an out of town FM station, but otherwise no problem

Quote this post ↓

A guest said: (hide)

How does this compare to the iTrip Auto? I have had this for week and it's good but not great. I'm wondering how it compares, or am i just aiming too high?

Quote this post ↓

A guest said: (hide)

Guest wrote:
How does this compare to the iTrip Auto? I have had this for week and it's good but not great. I'm wondering how it compares, or am i just aiming too high?

I am guest #1, I really need to get a username here. Anyway, finding an unused frequency is important. It took me a few minutes to get three of them and I have never had to reprogram the iCarPlay, I have always found a preset that is interference free.

Of course the best thing is to have an "audio in" jack to the car stereo, but I have other budget priorities right now

Quote this post ↓

Misha said:

member since 04 Apr 2005 with 9 posts, unranked, send him a message or view his profile

Guest wrote:
How does this compare to the iTrip Auto? I have had this for week and it's good but not great. I'm wondering how it compares, or am i just aiming too high?

I reviewed the iTrip Auto earlier this year, you can read the review here:

http://www.ipodobserver.com/story/24960

While one of my biggest gripes with the iTrip Auto was its price--and the Monster iCarPlay Wireless Plus costs about the same--the Monster definitely has more quality behind it to help it justify that price (plus handy presets).

Quote this post ↓

gslusher said:

member since 13 Nov 2002 with 2088 posts, unranked, send him a message or view his profile

Quote:
Of course the best thing is to have an "audio in" jack to the car stereo ...

Nope, that's second-best. The best thing is to have an iPod-specific connection tha uses the dock connector, as that can give you the use of your stereo controls, including the steering wheel controls. More and more cars are coming with iPod support built-in plus there are at least two after-market devices, one by Monster the other by Peripheral Electronics, the iPod2Car

http://peripheralelectronics.com/web/ipod2car.asp

They also have a version that works with after-market radios.

Quote this post ↓

A guest said: (hide)

Hello,

I was just wondering if the iCarPlay Wireless Plus can always be plugged in, or if you have to unplugg it when you leaving the car?

Quote this post ↓

Post Your Comments

  Remember Me

Not a member? Register now. You can post comments without logging in, but they'll show up as a "guest" post.


Please enter the word exactly as you see it in the image above. Registered users aren't prompted for this. Having trouble reading the image get a new one.