Review

iTunes TV Review - Battlestar Galactica 3.5: "Torn"

"Torn"
Airdate: Friday, November 3rd, 2006

You all knew it was coming, right? Finally, after whiling away the hours on such important projects as mustache shaving and calling Lee a fatass, Adama gets his Big Frakkin' Awesome Moment. And I loved every second! No one lays the smack down like Edward James Olmos. Like, who can even compare? The grizzled leader guy on NCISJAGWHATEVER? No. Simon Cowell? I don't think so, and also did that reference just arrive in a time machine from 2002? The smoky black cloud thing on Lost? Uh, did the smoky black cloud thing on Lost refer to its former daughter figure as a cancer? It did not.

I guess I should back up a little bit. Said smackdown comes about thanks to Kara and Tigh acting like big jerks in the mess hall. They basically posture and piss everyone off, trying to brew even more conflict between the folks who were on New Caprica and the folks who weren't. Adama finally stomps in, tosses a gun on the table and tells them to just shoot him, already or -- as my mother used to say -- act right. And he calls Kara a cancer -- a cancer! I still can't get over that.

Anyway, Kara actually seems a bit moved by his words and chops her hair into a trim pageboy. I will admit, I don't like it as much as her long, pretty hair, but it's infinitely superior to the bowl cut she rocked way back when. She also reconnects with Casey after rebuffing the kid in an extremely harsh way. And here I just have to praise Katee Sackhoff a whole lot, because that scene where she's hugging the kid and stuff? It could have been maudlin and annoyingly heartstring-yanking and all that. And if you thought that it was all that, please, please...look at her eyes. Her eyes are so conflicted, so deeply afraid. She's heartbreaking in this moment, and though we don't feel like everything's going to be totally OK, we at least feel like things could maybe get a little bit better, that Kara might be reconnecting with her humanity after all. I like this, because I had sort of assumed we were going to be subjected to Angry All The Time! Kara for at least a few more episodes. This turn offers more room for growth, for developments we haven't seen before.

Tigh, on the other hand... Well, he basically tells Adama to frak himself and stumbles off drunkenly and has hallucinations of Ellen. And that's really how it had to be in keeping true to who Tigh is, but it's sad all the same.

In other Galactica-set developments, Sharon earns herself a callsign and it's the sweetest moment in the whole hour (although it's kind of ruined by Kara and Tigh being haters). I love this so much, because it really shows us what the series can do with such a small, small moment. Sharon's discomfort with being called "Boomer," Helo's determination to make his wife feel like she belongs, the eventual christening of Sharon with the awesomely old school callsign "Athena"...all such good stuff.

Meanwhile, Baltar gets a big fat tour of the Cylon lifestyle and it's every bit as insane and juicy as you might imagine. It is also about as druggy hallucination-esque as the "Heffalumps and Woozles" bit from Winnie the Pooh and the Blustery Day. At least I can't say the Cylons are boring this week! Baltar learns all about the Cylons' "projection power," which is sort of like their own version of the holodeck, only, you know, more awesome. He is also introduced to their weird-ass "Hybrid" pilot, who speaks in some sort of incomprehensible Darmok language. Oh, and those other Cylon models we've never seen? They don't talk about those. Oh, and the Cylons want to settle on Earth! What...what?!?

Also, Baltar might be a Cylon...but I kind of don't think so, since that theory is to this show as "they are all totally in purgatory!" is to Lost.

Both Galactica and the Cylons end up sending teams to investigate this pretty cool double nebula, which is maybe a signpost for Earth. The Cylon scout ship is infected by a nasty virus and Baltar volunteers to investigate. He discovers a weird satellite thingy onboard, but completely neglects to mention this to the Cylons. I have a feeling Caprica Six is going to dump his ass even more in the next episode.

We're left hanging as to what happens to the human team, but, sigh, Sharon's with them and is suddenly dangerously close to that virus-ridden Cylon ship and I think I bit all of my nails off as we faded to credits. So much beautiful, beautiful tension.

I have to say, I really think this eppy does everything last week's eppy should have, and that makes me very happy. We're seeing gripping character development with both Kara and Tigh and we're feeling the effects of the New Caprica debacle in a way that's deep and true. And while being on the Cylon ship still makes me feel floaty and swirly-eyed, it's about 1000 percent more fascinating this week.

All this, plus Fat Apollo is not Fat anymore. I guess he jump-roped a lot.

iTunes Links

Battlestar Galactica - Series
Battlestar Galactica - Season 3
"Torn"


Need more? Talk about Battlestar Galactica in our new iPodObserver.com forums.

Sarah Kuhn is an L.A.-dwelling writer with a weakness for block-style action figures, spandex-clad superheroes, and the collected works of Joss Whedon. Her work has appeared in such fine publications as Back Stage, IGN.com, Creative Screenwriting Weekly, and StarTrek.com. You can catch her geekblogging at Alert Nerd and Great Hera!.

Battlestar Galactica Archives.

9 comments from the community.

You can post your own below.

+ show options

Your current settings, click to change: Sort Oldest First, Show Guest Posts, Hide Community Stats

DanielDecker said:

member since 15 Apr 2005 with 23 posts, unranked, send him a message or view his profile

I love reading your reviews of BSG 75. It doesn't hurt that you are obviously a genius, as you pick up on all the things I do, and you seem to have the passion for the show that allows you to be engulfed, yet remain critical. I get the feeling that you were as heartbroken as I was when RDM mentioned '...4 or 5 seasons...' in a podcast as a possible run for the whole show. How can this show ever end? Besides, we all know Sci Fi will give it the boot ( a la Farscape ) at the end of the season, just cuz they can't seem to figure out what to do when they have a hit on their hands. Maybe they'll bring back 'Tremors: the Series', that WAS awesome,

Quote this post ↓

A guest said: (hide)

Better.

Quote this post ↓

A guest said: (hide)

can we start a campaign to have Maxim request a photo shoot with Sarah : )

Quote this post ↓

Bosco said:

member since 03 Jun 2002 with 999 posts, unranked, send him a message or view his profile

To answer Daniel's question, one way this show could end is if they find earth, eliminate the Cyclons, build some pyramids, and break off into tribes to mingle with the natives and rebuild humanity over the next 10,000 years. Another way it could end is if EJO gets in a car accident or has a stroke and can't act anymore. The show wouldn't be believable without him. It's not like they could stick Alec Baldwin in there and keep continuity. "ABC: Always Be (Killing) Cylons." Same with any of the Cylons.

The resolution of the Fat Apollo affair was super corny. "Don't let me get that way again." OK, Lee. Stick to the Zone Diet, no complex carbs, take your diahretics, and only a few sips of water after working out. You'll look great. And no stretch marks! Has anyone here ever lost 10 pounds? Also I have to watch it again, but I bet it was a body double.

Quote this post ↓

A guest said: (hide)

<i>have to say, I really think this eppy does everything last week's eppy should have, and that makes me very happy.</i>

Hate to continue to disagree with you Sarah, but last week's eppy ('Collaborators') was both necessary AND good. It just didn't have exploding battlestars or cylon-living going for it. What it did have was some very important ideas that are tremendously relevant to us right here, right now.

Other than that, loved your review. Keep up the good work.

Quote this post ↓

A guest said: (hide)

have to say, I really think this eppy does everything last week's eppy should have, and that makes me very happy.

Hate to continue to disagree with you Sarah, but last week's eppy ('Collaborators') was both necessary AND good. It just didn't have exploding battlestars or cylon-living going for it. What it did have was some very important ideas that are tremendously relevant to us right here, right now.

Other than that, loved your review. Keep up the good work.

Quote this post ↓

A guest said: (hide)

On 'Torn'- Loved Baltar living among the Cylons. Makes sense, and is 'old school' BSG in all the right ways. Do hope that there's a moment where Baltar is sitting in a tall chair with a light shining up into his face... now THAT's a holla to the old BSG, and how.

Loved Starbuck getting her comeuppance by probably the only guy in the fleet with the stones to do it, aka EJO. Starbuck's character is SUPPOSED to be flawed, I get that, but lately (going back to late Season 2) she has been SO obnoxious and bullying that I actually cheered when Adama kicked the chair out from under her. Hate to say it, but she obviously needs that once in awhile. As it stands, the best pilot in the fleet is now Kat, simply because she's not a headcase like Starbuck (since she went off the stims, anyway).

The 'Cylon-lifestyle' scenes were awesome and so much more interesting than in the original BSG. This is SOOOO genius, having Baltar live among the Cylons, and not just because they did it on the original series. Baltar's number one characteristic is saving his own ass, he's at his best and most interesting when he's doing that. And it looks like he's going to have to do that on a near-weekly basis now that he's living among the Cylons! Genius!

Oh, and its interesting that the Six in Baltar's head (who we now know is NOT Caprica Six) referred to herself as 'an angel of God sent to do God's will'. Hmm... can anyone else here think of a major character that was in the original series who has yet to make an appearance in the new series? And what was the name of the most famous angel of them all?

I admit that I've had this theory for awhile, it's nice to see that me and RDM seem to be on the same page.

Finally, regarding RDM's '4 or 5 seasons comment'... it makes total sense. 5 seasons would just about cover it, don't you think? I don't expect this series to be dragged out forever, that would slowly kill eveything we love about BSG by reducing it to mediocrity.. I'd expect that they find Earth by the end of S3, spend all of S4 dealing with Earth (which should a lot more problematic than it was in 'BSG 1980') and the threats to it; and then S5 wraps up the whole ball of wax.

And I'm SO looking forward to it.

Quote this post ↓

DanielDecker said:

member since 15 Apr 2005 with 23 posts, unranked, send him a message or view his profile

Raise you hand if have actually met EJO. (picture me raising my hand...) Had the great fortune to have him come and speak to my Acting 2 class in college. The man IS a pressence. That experience is one of the reasons I'm so emotionally connected to this show. I KNOW 4 or 5 seasons is a good run for the show, but it's hard to think about losing a good friend, you know. Besides, RDM gave us 7 good seasons on Deep Space Nine. I will reiterate, no matter ehat the producers intend, this show is in the hands of Sci Fi, and their track record speaks for itself.

Quote this post ↓

Bryan said:

member since 11 Jun 2001 with 7331 posts, TMO Staff, send him a message or view his profile

Anonymous wrote:
On 'Torn'- Loved Baltar living among the Cylons. Makes sense, and is 'old school' BSG in all the right ways. Do hope that there's a moment where Baltar is sitting in a tall chair with a light shining up into his face... now THAT's a holla to the old BSG, and how.

I have so been hoping for such a scene, too! That's just funny.

Quote this post ↓

Post Your Comments

  Remember Me

Not a member? Register now. You can post comments without logging in, but they'll show up as a "guest" post.


Please enter the word exactly as you see it in the image above. Registered users aren't prompted for this. Having trouble reading the image get a new one.