Review

Review - AudioStation

Most iPod-specific speaker systems on the market are just that: speaker systems. While many are excellently suited for breaking your iPod free from its earphones, few do anything beyond that, curtailing their ability to be a true stereo system replacement. Logitech's new AudioStation changes all this, packing all the features one could possibly want in an iPod speaker system, including an AM/FM radio, digital clock, auxilliary input and video out support, and a robust remote control.

AudioStation

Not surprisingly, the AudioStation represents the pinnacle of Logitech's iPod speaker offerings and commands a price tag of $299, pitting it against Klipsch's iGroove HG ($249, 4 stars), Altec Lansing's iM7 ($249), Bose's SoundDock ($299, 2 stars), and Apple's iPod Hi-Fi ($349, 4 stars). None of those other systems come close to matching the AudioStation's features, however, and just one—the iPod H-Fi—can do something the AudioStation cannot: display artwork full-screen against a black background when a track is playing on a 5G iPod (why this feature remains unique to Apple is a mystery).

AudioStation
Logitech AudioStation with AM antenna, remote, and power supply

In addition to overflowing the features list, Logitech seems to have anticipated most customer desires, learning from its own experience and that of competitors. Like Apple's iPod Hi-Fi, for example, all controls on the front of the AudioStation are touch-sensitive—there's no flimsy feeling buttons to press or plastic to flex. The AudioStation also sports its own bass and treble controls, so you can forgo the iPod's EQ and adjust the sound to your preference directly, a capability one would expect on systems at this price point but that nonetheless is missing from both the iGroove and SoundDock, to name a couple.

The included external FM antenna does a commendable job of receiving broadcasts, and the AudioStation's display will tell you the signal strength and any RDS information, like the name of the station and currently playing track, if the station broadcasts such information. The built-in AM antenna faired less well in our tests, but connecting the external antenna significantly improved reception. Radio controls are also up to par with stereo system standards, supporting both presets and scanning.

iGrooveiGroove

Every aspect of the AudioStation can be controlled from the remote, except for setting radio station presets. This includes specifying input source, controlling basic playback, toggling repeat or shuffle, changing radio stations, and adjusting the bass and treble level. Also conveniently located on the remote control is a button for setting the AudioStation's sleep timer, which can be specified in increments of five minutes.

Despite sporting a large digital clock display and its own sleep functionality, the AudioStation is disappointingly lacking an alarm clock. You can replicate that functionality by setting the alarm clock on your iPod, as the AudioStation will automatically turn itself on when your iPod starts playing, but doing so is more cumbersome than a built-in alarm clock would be and requires you to remember to dock your iPod before bed each night.

Acoustics are handled courtesy of two 1-inch ventilated soft-dome, ultra-linear tweeters and two 4-inch reinforced long-throw, high-efficiency polypropylene woofers. Audio quality overall is very good, but not enough to call class-leading; both the iGroove and iPod Hi-Fi created a marginally richer listening experience for our ears, and stand-alone speaker systems, like Audioengine's A5 ($349, 5 stars) and Gini's iTube ($349, 4 stars) are noticeably superior.

Unique to the AudioStation, however, is a 3D stereo mode designed to widen the sound field. We tend to approach such audio enhancement modes with often-justified skepticism, but in the case of the AudioStation the 3D stereo mode created a discernible difference in widening the perceived direction of the audio without overdoing it or compromising quality. We found ourselves listening to the AudioStation with the 3D stereo feature usually turned on.

AudioStation
The AudioStation's LCD display serves several purposes

For all of its strong points, the AudioStation does have a few minor shortcomings: its overall design is uninspiring; the LCD display is slow to respond to changes, resulting in ghosting when things like the basic EQ levels monitor is turned on; and the touch-sensitive controls themselves exhibit a short, but noticeable, delay when pressed, making fine tuning the volume or other levels trickier than with the remote.

The Bottom Line

Logitech is trying to position the AudioStation as the be-all and end-all of iPod speaker systems and, for the most, has succeeded. From the universal dock to the AM/FM radio to the S-Video/RCA video-out options, the AudioStation can practically do it all, and makes your music sound very good along the way.

If extra bells and whistles in an iPod speaker system are worth it to you, the AudioStation is well worth its price tag.

Just The Facts

AudioStation from Logitech

MSRP US$299.99 / Street Price: $248.99.

Pros: packed with features, commendable audio quality, robust remote control, reasonable price

Cons: no alarm clock functionality, touch-sensitive controls exhibit slight delay

4 comments from the community.

You can post your own below.

+ show options

Your current settings, click to change: Sort Oldest First, Show Guest Posts, Hide Community Stats

gslusher said:

member since 13 Nov 2002 with 2088 posts, unranked, send him a message or view his profile

Alas, this is not a "true stereo system replacement," unless one has only a rudimentary stereo system.

- Lacks 5.1 support

- Lacks digital audio input (optical cable)

- Lacks multiple inputs and outputs, including video switching

and more.

Quote this post ↓

A guest said: (hide)

I am mostly happy with the Audiostation. The sound is warm, rich with a deep bass that is able to fill a room. What I mostly miss is a wider stereo perspective, which of course is due to the close position of the speakers.

Other small annoyances: I miss a handle to make it easier to move from one room to another - and the separate power supply brick you need to hold in your other hand when you move the speaker system.

I have not been able to make the display show song info from the iPod ... I guess I need to look in the manual (which tells you that this is not an Apple product

Quote this post ↓

Misha said:

member since 04 Apr 2005 with 9 posts, unranked, send him a message or view his profile

gslusher: Your points are valid, but to clarify, by "stereo replacement" I was referring to the more typical three-piece stereo systems that sell in the same price range as most iPod speakers ($100-$300). Naturally, no all-in-one system can replace a proper receiver and 5.1/7.1 speaker system, but comparing apples to apples, the AudioStation is the first iPod speaker system that can effectively replace those CD/radio/dual-tape-deck (why?)/two-big-speakers setups.

Also, you will find many people dislike listening to stereo music (myself included) through a 5.1 setup that uses Dolby Pro Logic or similar post-processing to split up the signals. Even a Stereo x2 configuration is less desirable at times. Also, I know very few affordable and portable consumer electronics devices that support digital audio out, which negates the need for the AudioStation to support digital audio out (which is typically used for surround sound, anyway, which is obviously unnecessary the 2-channel AudioStation). Not to mention the iPod itself only supports stereo and not 5.1.

Guest: The track information displayed in the photo above is actually the RDS information from a radio station. There is no way to display the iPod's track info on the AudioStation's display, alas.

Quote this post ↓

A guest said: (hide)

i like the product, i bought it last December ... but i have problem with its power supply now,easily damaged (short circuit) by cellphone signal...now i dont know where to buy my replacement.. I'm from the Philippines, Logitech please help!!!!!!

Quote this post ↓

Post Your Comments

  Remember Me

Not a member? Register now. You can post comments without logging in, but they'll show up as a "guest" post.


Please enter the word exactly as you see it in the image above. Registered users aren't prompted for this. Having trouble reading the image get a new one.