Column

Just A Thought - The iPod/iPhone/eBook Connection

Everybody's talking about iPhone: what it will do, what it won't do, and is it worth the cost. I've even speculated on what might be in store for iPhone users.

One thing that some people still don't seem to understand is that, like the iPod, the iPhone is platform, a handheld computer, if you will, that just happens to let you make calls.

But that's not what I want to talk about, there more than enough media coverage on this device, so I really can't add anything significant.

What I want to talk about are eBooks.

I'll wait until you're done yawning.

There's an article that appeared about a year ago over at Engadget that claimed to have inside info that Apple is thinking about entering the eBook market. Yawn again if you'd like. A year has come and gone and there hasn't been a peep out of Apple about eBook readers.

To me the idea has merit, but truth be told I yawn whenever someone mentions eBook in the same sentence as iPod - that is until I saw this eBook Reader Design Proposal out on YouTube.

Dock an iPod loaded with eBooks on the back, open it to read the ePaper bounded inside. Pretty good idea.

Now this is an eye opener. The idea is a solid one; use the iPod as the brains that docks with an ePaper based eBook reader. The infrastructure for finding and downloading eBooks is already available in the iPod and iTunes Store. If the iPod had tons of storage, you could conceivably carry your entire library with you on vacation, which, of course, you can do now, but with this idea, you might actually read something.

What is also interesting in that there may finally be a way to electronically get periodicals to subscribers that rival print. In fact, with an ePaper text reader, nearly anything, be it handwritten or typed, can be transmitted, downloaded, stored, and ultimately read in almost the same manner as paper documents.

Also, as ePaper finds more widespread use the cost of producing the it will fall, which means that it may be possible to put entire collections of important books in the hands of those who can least afford them. Basically, I'm saying that every kid could have an entire set of encyclopedias, the latest text books, and the best learning tools available to him or her regardless of their social or economic standing. Backpacks would shrink dramatically, much to the jubilation of every kid in America.

The down side? There are some.

While ePaper comes the closest yet to printed paper it still requires power, albeit very little power, to be used. ePaper can't show color photos or any multicolored image yet. ePaper displays can't change fast enough for quality animation, so forget about watching movies. And this is still just speculation. Steve Jobs has yet to lay this one on us much less hinted that Apple is even thinking about such a thing.

Beyond that I really can't think of any show stoppers. Actually, with the impending release of the iPhone there's even more reasons to hope that Apple takes a serious look at this proposal: Internet access from anywhere.

Along with being able to dock with the ePaper device I would propose that it be Bluetooth capable so that it can link to an iPhone. You could leave your iPhone in your pocket or take calls and still read documents from the Internet, even Web pages. It seems a perfect match.

The only other thing I would add to this proposal is a way to write on ePaper and have the results stored in your iPod. That would complete the circle and in many cases eliminate the need for regular paper.

This eBook Reader Design Proposal is a good idea and I hope someone at Apple takes this seriously. This is an idea that might actually work.


Vern Seward is a writer who currently lives in Orlando, FL. He's been a Mac fan since Atari Computers folded, but has worked with computers of nearly every type for 20 years.

Just a Thought Archives.

14 comments from the community.

You can post your own below.

+ show options

Your current settings, click to change: Sort Oldest First, Show Guest Posts, Hide Community Stats

A guest said: (hide)

yawn

Quote this post ↓

A guest said: (hide)

It's a very old idea. Like 5 years old or more. I still don't quite know why no one has done it, since the ePaper technology has been around for a while. I always just assumed that the resolution of the paper or the cost or something just wasn't good enough.

Also, Steve might not be willing to get into something that takes us back to the days of black-and-white with no animation. Maybe he's waiting on the color versions. Bill Gates mentioned those in that D interview.

Just imagine Apple trying to make a black and white version of Safari. I didn't think so.

(But I woult buy one, esp if I could write on it.)

Quote this post ↓

Biff said:

member since 08 Apr 2004 with 1479 posts, unranked, send him a message or view his profile

Just when you thought that guy on the train with the portable DVD player was a dork, along comes a guy with one of these! Yikes!

Quote this post ↓

Skribbler said:

member since 19 Jun 2007 with 1 posts, unranked, send him a message or view his profile

I think Apple may be preparing a new iPod with the iPhone screen. Turned horizontally it should easily be good enough to function as a reader.

Quote this post ↓

A guest said: (hide)

The problem is reading it outside on the beach or by the pool. It is much too bright in the sun for one to read the screen as well as a book with print.

Quote this post ↓

WetcoastBob said:

member since 17 Aug 2006 with 80 posts, unranked, send him a message or view his profile

Didn"t Palm do this sort of thing a few years ago? Seems to me that I remember a buddy showing me a device which could house a few books.

In any event this would be very handy, particularly if pictures and diagrams could be included. It would be a perfect reference library for trades people, polititions ,teachers and so on.

I like the thought of having my camera manual or a dictionary with me without lugging my MBP.

Connected with an iPhone in your pocket you could preview the menus of restaurants in your vicinity or check sale prices at Home Depot.

You could even include ear-buds and store some music on it and use it as a portable music player

The possibilities are endless.

Quote this post ↓

A guest said: (hide)

Yes, Sony did this a few years back. Problem is, that with only black and white available, it's just not "cool" enough yet. And Apple is all about being cool. Now a device that would connect via bluetooth to the iphone and use it's 3G capabilities to surf the web, get Back to my Mac, "auto-Google" nearby locations based on GPS, etc? Now THAT would be cool. Heck, throw an isight camera into the thing and ichat wirelessly. That's the kind of integration that is needed. I think Apple is building "pieces parts" of some larger ecosystem. They are just doing it stealthily enough to not tip off the guys at Redmond as to what they are doing.

Quote this post ↓

Dreadnought said:

member since 01 Jan 2005 with 161 posts, unranked, send him a message or view his profile

I don't know why Apple can't implement this into the iPod, except for the backlight/ battery life issue. Given how dark the screen is without the backlight, reading a PDF would be near impossible without it. However, I've found that leaving the backlight on drains the power significantly - I have an older iPod I use just in my car, which has a battery life of 8 hours, and since it's always connected to a power source, I have the backlight set to never turn off. I had left my regular iPod in the dock one day and was using the car iPod and didn't realize the backlight was constantly on. I got about 4 hours out of it.

But - it would be a great idea - especially since I already use iTunes to manage a PDF library.

Quote this post ↓

A guest said: (hide)

Clearing up a few misconceptions here:

1) E-ink is easily read in the sun.

2) E-ink displays do not use a backlight and are extremely energy-efficient.

3) I find it hard to believe this is a "very old idea..like 5 years old or more"...considering that five years ago (June 2002) the iPod was still first generation and not widely sold. Ebook readers are indeed an old concept but have not caught on precisely because of deficient designs, which this proposal attempts to address.

4) Neither Palm nor Sony "did this thing a few years back" - the whole concept here is that the iPod is docked into the back of the reader, making it an affordable, book-like accessory. Take a look at the YouTube video if this is not clear.

5) Colour e-ink displays have been developed though I'm not sure they're ready for mass marketing. The pros and cons of colour are worth debating but I see no reason why a "first-generation" reader could not be successful in black-and-white, as the iPod was all the way through 2004. By the time the market is established through iTunes - probably after about two years - colour e-ink displays will be widely available and consumers ready for an upgrade. Indeed, the trajectory of this particular concept could mirror the iPod's in many ways.

5) Turning an iPod or iPhone sideways might be okay for some people but the general public will want something that feels like a book: that is, something about the size of a paperback, with two screens. I'll never feel comfortable reading The Economist on my iPod, my Palm, my iPhone, or anything else that's only the size of my hand.

Quote this post ↓

Terrin said:

member since 29 Jan 2006 with 376 posts, unranked, send him a message or view his profile

I do a lot of reading. For me, I dislike eBooks because the experience is never as good as reading a book. For starters, there is no glare when reading a book. Books are not too bright. I can bend, drop, and get wet a book. As another person stated, books are bigger and have two pages.

I want to like ebooks because fitting a whole library in a small device would be cool. I just don't.

Quote this post ↓

A guest said: (hide)

I wonder what app Apple will provide to read e-books on the iPhone? I think it would be a better e-book reader than something like a Treo, which I use currently.

Quote this post ↓

A guest said: (hide)

Iphone book reader

BooksOnIphone.com

Iphone native application for reading books on Iphone. Works fast and supports all iphone buttons and commands.

Access thousands of books for FREE on IPhone. Upload any text (stories, poems, novels, articles, esseys, lectures etc.) so you can read it anytime and anywhere or share it with others. Upload and publish from your desktop, blog, send by email, or use your IPhone. Share your E-books.

TextonIphone.com

Read multiple books simultaniously. Add and share notes and reviews.

Quote this post ↓

A guest said: (hide)

Why stop at an iPod / reader hybrid? Why not take the iPhone concept, enlarge it into a low-end tablet/slate that can surf the web, do email, perform light computing duties <em>and</em> display ebooks. Sort of like <a href="http://wowio.wordpress.com/2007/07/10/iphone-mac-itablet-the-ideal-ebook-reader/">this</a>.

Quote this post ↓

A guest said: (hide)

Here's a free iPhone eBook reader with a growing supply of free eBooks too! (No installation necessary)

http://iPhonePlaza.net/books/

Quote this post ↓

Post Your Comments

  Remember Me

Not a member? Register now. You can post comments without logging in, but they'll show up as a "guest" post.


Please enter the word exactly as you see it in the image above. Registered users aren't prompted for this. Having trouble reading the image get a new one.