Column

Just A Thought - Damn You Apple And The Earbuds You Rode In With!

Apple is known for its design genius, its attention to detail, and its stubbornness.

It is my opinion that only a constipated mule with sore feet is more obstinate than Apple when it latches onto an idea it believes in. Apple will stand firm against herds of angry stampeding end users if it thinks its philosophy is worth defending.

Need an example? How about the one-button mouse. It was a good idea for a while; it was elegant and easy to understand. It was the epitome of ease, the symbol of simplicity, but the advantage of the one-button mouse became moot with the introduction of Mac OS X and true multitasking. People grew to see the usefulness of the two and three button mouse and complained constantly the one button just wasn't enough. Still, Apple stuck by that one-button like bubble gum on your shoe on a hot Summer day.

Eventually Apple did concede that three buttons are better than one and started including the former with every Mac. Of course, they had to do it with the customary Apple flare.

This time it's those silly earbuds that the company introduced to the world with the iPod. Just like the one-button mouse was the picture of proficiency, earbuds became the icon of cool: wear them and everyone knew you had it going on.

However, as many runway models will tell you, there's a price to pay for cool. For me that price is pain: whenever I wear earbuds for more than 5 minutes my ear hurts. It seems my anti-tragus is too small to effectively keep earbuds in place (and they say size doesn't matter) and I've been putting undo stress on my tragus (the little flap of gristle and skin at the entrance of the ear canal).

If I adjust the buds so that they don't hurt, they get loose and sound horrible and I have to constantly push them back in, which is also a pain. Forget about dancing around like they do in those iPod commercials, when I start hopping the earbuds start popping and I'm forced to stop the hop and re-plug the buds.

What's worse is that nearly ever other digital music player maker, in an attempt to equal iPod's cool, insists on including those stupid earbuds with their players. Shame on them! Have an independent thought, why don't you!

My question to Apple is this: Couldn't you have come up with a design that does not cause pain for the earbud-challenged? I guess Sony had already cornered the dinky headset market, and your design had to be radically different, and I get that. I really do, but while we may all be equal in the eyes of the law our ears are only more or less so.

Just like you gave in and start selling three-button mice with your Macs, maybe it's time for you to think about something new to put in our ears. It doesn't have to be fancy or hi-tech, just something that works and doesn't require ears like Dumbo to use.

With the iPhone, you folks in Cupertino had an excellent opportunity to make a clean start ear-phonically speaking, but what did you do? You make more earbuds! Even the fabled Apple Bluetooth headset appears to be little more the a wireless earbud with an Apple logo on it.

Come on Apple! It's time to give up the buds, Bud. Give the lab geeks an extra case of Red Bull and set them loose, see what they come up with. I bet a real American dollar that whatever they think up, it'll be less painful than those trauma-inducing earbuds. The millions of us with sore traguses will thank you.


Vern Seward is a writer who currently lives in Orlando, FL. He's been a Mac fan since Atari Computers folded, but has worked with computers of nearly every type for 20 years.

Just a Thought Archives.

8 comments from the community.

You can post your own below.

+ show options

Your current settings, click to change: Sort Oldest First, Show Guest Posts, Hide Community Stats

Sir Harry Flashman said:

member since 08 Feb 2007 with 721 posts, unranked, send him a message or view his profile

Allow me to bud in here. I pretty much agree with you Vern, I had that problem with supplied iPod ear buds. I put on some silicon earbud covers that were kind of like the foam things Apple supplies, they helped a lot. Eventually I replaced my G.I. earbuds and am currently using Griffin Earjams and like them a lot.

Quote this post ↓

A guest said: (hide)

" Of course, they had to do it with the customary Apple flare."

...and "flair" too.

Quote this post ↓

A guest said: (hide)

Have you considered plastic surgery for your ear problem? Maybe some collagen injections? :^D

Quote this post ↓

macinnerd said:

member since 15 Jun 2005 with 1710 posts, unranked, send him a message or view his profile

I love my iPod earbuds. They fit my ears perfectly. However this only applies to the new October 2005 iPod earbuds, the old ones were indeed very painful. I couldn't get them to fit. And when they did it really hurt.

Quote this post ↓

Sir Harry Flashman said:

member since 08 Feb 2007 with 721 posts, unranked, send him a message or view his profile

macinnerd wrote:
I love my iPod earbuds. They fit my ears perfectly. However this only applies to the new October 2005 iPod earbuds, the old ones were indeed very painful. I couldn't get them to fit. And when they did it really hurt.

Well I may get a chance to try the new Apple earbuds, late yesterday afternoon my 4th generation iPod gave up the ghost. The dreaded clicking hard drive of death. I tried resets and all the tricks from the Apple Support Discussions, no joy. Of course if I buy a new iPod next month Apple will probably introduce a new model with an iPhone like interface. My wife said I could have her iPod Photo which she only uses during the commute, I could burn her some CDs. My son also has an 2nd generation iPod that is just sitting in the drawer and I can have that.

Quote this post ↓

Intruder said:

member since 07 Jul 2004 with 3012 posts, TMO Mac Specialist, send him a message or view his profile

You might try "percussive maintenance."

Take the iPod and give it a reasonable thump on a desk top.

Seriously. (you have nothing to lose anyway!)

Quote this post ↓

Sir Harry Flashman said:

member since 08 Feb 2007 with 721 posts, unranked, send him a message or view his profile

Intruder wrote:
You might try "percussive maintenance."

Take the iPod and give it a reasonable thump on a desk top.

Seriously. (you have nothing to lose anyway!)

I was thinking of disassembling it just to see what is inside.

I think the hard drive failed, I have a lot of hours/miles on it.

Anyway I snagged the wife's photo iPod and loaded my playlists, but left hers in place. Like I said she mostly used it while commuting to and fro, I can make her some CD's (how very 1990s).

After seeing the iPhone, I am speculating that Apple will have something similar in the next iPod. Bigger screen, Cover Flow, maybe a notepad, and other non-phone specific things. By not having the cell phone hardware they could have room for a mini-hard drive. I will wait it out a while before buying a new iPod at least until the January MacWorld Expo. Besides I would be better served putting the money into upgrading to Adobe CS3.

Quote this post ↓

Hieronymus Murphy said:

member since 02 Apr 2007 with 10 posts, unranked, send him a message or view his profile

Perhaps Apple should simply start including their $39 premium earbuds with each iPod.

I, too, have small ear canals and had trouble with the stock earbuds, then bought the premium 'buds — and I've been happy ever since.

Quote this post ↓

Post Your Comments

  Remember Me

Not a member? Register now. You can post comments without logging in, but they'll show up as a "guest" post.


Please enter the word exactly as you see it in the image above. Registered users aren't prompted for this. Having trouble reading the image get a new one.