You're viewing an article in iPO's historic archive vault. Here, we've preserved the comments and how the site looked along with the article. Use this link to view the article on our current site: The Simplified Guide to HDTV Buying

News

iPO Reports - The Simplified Guide to HDTV Buying

HDTV technology can be complex, and buying a first-time system can be a daunting task. This article will describe, in high level terms, the most important things you need to know if you're planing an HDTV system this holiday. As an added bonus, there is a companion article, the Detailed Guide, that goes into more detail for those who want it.

The subject can be confusing. You just want to get into High Definition TV (HDTV) this holiday season with a minimum of fuss. You don't want to get bogged down with technical details, yet you want to make smart decisions.

That's in contrast to HDTV buying for geeks for whom getting into all the technical details, optimizations, and system configurations is all the fun. That's a road not taken in this simplified guide. I'll tell you the most important things that will keep you from making a big mistake, and then if you want more details on one or more items, you can check the companion article.

Where I've added hyperlinks in this article, you can click to find out more in the companion article that goes into more detail. All set?

What You Need to Know

1. HD Source - The very first thing you need to do is decide on the source of your high definition content. Most if not all cable and satellite carriers have upgrade packages, and you'll need to check on their pricing, packages, then order HDTV service. It's compatible with your current standard definition (SD) TV, so getting that piece into place first will pay off when the new equipment is brought home. Do this now. More details

2. Flat Screen or Rear Projection? - There are two kinds of HDTVs. The first, rear projection, uses a light source that shines on a special surface to create the image, then lenses and mirrors project that image from behind onto the front screen of the TV. The rear projection TVs are somewhat bulky, not too heavy -- because there's mostly empty air inside -- and can be somewhat unsightly because they need to be about 12 to 15 inches deep to make room for a big mirror inside.

The advantage of the rear projection TVs is that you get a big screen size for your money. Much more so than thin, flat screens. The disadvantage is that the technology is dying because customers love the thin LCDs and Plasmas, and in some older models, there may be an expensive lamp to replace in the future. Rear projection TVs cannot be hung on the wall. Buy one only if money is really tight, you want a big screen, and don't care about impending obsolescence.

There are two major kinds of thin, flat screen TVs, LCD and Plasma. They are more expensive than the rear projection TVs for a given screen size, but are generally less than 4 inches thick, look great, and tend to have a brighter display.

The advantage is that they can be hung on a wall, look more modern, have no moving parts, and don't use a big internal mirror which can sometimes introduce minor distortions. Prices are way down from last year, so you will probably want to go with one of the flat screen TVs. More details

3. LCD or Plasma? - Everything you have read about Plasmas is probably obsolete. Modern Plasma flat screen HDTVs no longer buzz, overheat or have significant worries of screen burn-in. They are a great choice because they have a deep, rich color most like the old CRT TVs we used for 60 years. They have a fast response time for action movies. Also, the new ones have special anti-reflection coatings, so if the salesman tells you that it won't work well in a bright room, he's using old and anecdotal information. I own a Plasma TV and it's good in daylight and fantastic in the evening with dim room lights.

LCD TVs started out not as good as Plasma but have made huge strides. They don't always have the darkest black levels, a desirable feature, don't always have fast response times, and can appear somewhat two dimensional compared to the Plasmas. However, the very latest 120 Hz LCDs, especially with LED backlighting are terrific (and expensive).

You will have to look for yourself and compare. Do NOT evaluate these TVs with animated movies or cartoons. Ask the salesman to see action movies that have some dark scenes, then compare the clarity, apparent depth, crispness in the dark areas, and smoothness of the picture when a scene pans.

Either way you go here will work. Based on my own experience, don't let a salesman steer you away from a Plasma if that's what you want. They have a terrific picture even in the daytime, and while LCDs often look brighter, older, cheaper models can't match Plasmas for overall quality.

If you can afford it, an LCD HDTV with a 120 Hz circuitry can equal the Plasmas displays and looks fantastic. Remember, even if you go with a less expensive LCD model, it'll look a gazillion times better than than the standard definition TV you have now. More details

4. Be Wary of Discount HDTVs - Thanks to a somewhat weak economy, I suspect merchants will be offering some really inexpensive HDTVs. The problem is that many of these TVs will be several years old, obsolete models, and may not have the features you need today.

4a. Inputs - Some older models will only have the Red, Blue, Green Component input plugs. Don't buy an HDTV without at least one HDMI input. HDMI carries both the picture and sound.

4b. Older Plasmas - A lot of older Plasmas were limited to 720p resolution, not so great lifetimes and may be offered at fire sale prices. If that's okay with you, go for it. But most of the new, modern Plasmas with a screen size of 40 inches or larger are now 1080p. I'd stay with that because a 1080p Plasma will be the latest technology and have a longer technical lifetime.

4c. Older LCDs - LCD HDTVs have made huge strides in picture quality, response time, brightness, and contrast levels. Don't buy an LCD TV made before mid-2007 unless you're willing to compromise on picture quality to save some money. More details

5. Where to Put the HDTV - Do NOT, I repeat, Do NOT try to mount a flat screen TV on the wall yourself. Have a professional installer from a local home theater store or Best Buy do it for you. There are structural and wiring issues that could lead to a dangerous situation if done by a first-timer.

If you put any HDTV in a cubby hole, Plasma or LCD, make sure there's plenty of ventilation. A 42-inch HDTV crammed into a home entertainment center/book case with a 42.5 inch opening will become a wiring and heating disaster. It's far better to mount these flat screen HDTVs on their pedestal out in the open air. If it looks like a big dog or child could knock it over, get some help securing it to a wall stud with a chain or strap. More details

6. Ethernet Availability - In the old days, all you needed was your cable TV plug and a power plug behind the TV. Recently, it's been necessary to also have a phone jack for some satellite systems. Nowadays, however, Ethernet, connected to the Internet, is increasingly important to have available behind your HDTV and related components. Get some help from a professional installer on how to extend Ethernet, either via a wire in the wall, or wirelessly, via Wi-Fi, from your home router so that your Apple TV, Blu-ray player, or some other component can access the Internet. This is increasingly important in 2008/2009. More details

7. What About Sound? - You have an important choice to make about sound. HDTV has digital surround sound on at least 6 channels, and the right kind of sound system can make a high definition movie breathtaking.

If you run all your HDTV sources, like cable, Blu-ray or Apple TV directly into your TV, assuming it has enough HDMI inputs, you'll only get simple two channel stereo out of the cheap speakers built into all HDTVs. That's a really low cost solution and a poor listening experience. Worse, if you don't have enough HDMI inputs, you have to resort to a more complicated wiring system for video and separate sound.

A better solution is to have a modern audio/video receiver that's designed to accept all kinds of inputs, HDMI, component audio, digital sound, and can send just the picture to your TV and the audio to the speakers you select. That way, your sound system can grow as your budget allows, and someday you might have all six channels thundering during a Blu-ray showing of Quantum of Solace. More details

8. Upgradability - I wouldn't buy a bundled system, say, an HDTV with a Blu-ray player inside. It looks like a deal, but it'll keep you from mixing and matching components in a flexible way, locks you into a specific technology that may not be the best, and adds complexity. If your internal Blu-ray player fails, you'll have to send a large, heavy TV back for repair, and it could become damaged, scratched, etc.

There's nothing wrong with buying one of the LG or Samsung players that features Netflix access. See item #6 above. You'll need Ethernet and Internet access for that. More details

9. Testing in the Store - HDTVs that were affordable in the past were rear projection, and some of them suffer from a lack of screen brightness. That's why they were put in darkened, home theater-like rooms. Meanwhile, the small, bright LCD HDTVs could be safely put out on the showroom floor.

Don't compare two TVs in two different rooms. Try to arrange for them to be next to each other. If that's not possible, try to compare two TVs of different types, even if they aren't the models you're after, that are near to each other. You'll get a feel for the kind of picture you like.

Good comparison sources are: action movies, ice hockey (watch the puck) and nature shows with lots of detail. Bad comparison sources are football, cartoons, and TV shows with indoor scenes. These won't really test the TV because their slowly moving, saturated colors look good on any TV. More details

10. Those Darn Salesmen - Many salesmen in mass merchandising stores like Target, Wall-Mart, and so on won't have the expertise and training to guide you. Worse, they'll depend on knowledge passed along or store owner guidance that won't be in your best interest. For example, some Satellite TV and, of course, Blu-ray players can output 1080p, but I've heard salesmen say you don't need it. Yes you do on any TV that's 46 inches or bigger and you sit fairly close. The 1080p resolution will insulate you from obsolescence. Don't settle for less, like 1080i or 720p native resolution, for your new HDTV if you plan to keep it for some time.

Some sales people will guide you away from a Plasma TV if you say it won't be placed in a dark area like a basement. That's simplistic today -- don't fall for that. Modern Plasmas do fine in all kinds of ambient lighting - except direct sunlight, which no flat screen can endure.

Packages can be cost savers. Many merchants will offer a discount on a Blu-ray player if you buy a more expensive HDTV. (But see #8 above.) Just make sure the Blu-ray player isn't an older, obsolete model that they're trying to unload. (I'll be writing a Blu-ray buyers guide soon.)

If they do offer you that bundle, remain a little skeptical and ask if they'll also throw in a copy or two of a Disney movie on Blu-ray for the kids on Christmas morning. Chances are, you'll get one or two thrown in just to close the deal.

Be miserly on cables. Don't get gouged on $99 HDMI cables. Apple stores sell them for $25. More details

Bottom Line

Armed with this information, chances are you won't make any big mistakes when you go shopping for an HDTV. If you're not real deep on the technology and trying to surprise a spouse at Christmas, take a friend along on your shopping trip who is aware of some of these issues. You won't get much meaningful help from the salesperson, but if the salesperson tries to take you down a questionable path, you'll have a friend to consult with.

If you're uncertain about any of the items here, the links will provide more technical depth. You may be uncertain about just an item or two, so don't feel compelled to read the full, detailed companion piece. It might overload you.

Print this article, scan it while watching (your old) TV, and take it with you when you shop. And happy viewing! HDTV is so fantastic, you'll wonder how you ever lived without it.

12 comments from the community.

You can post your own below.

+ show options

Your current settings, click to change: Sort Oldest First, Show Guest Posts, Hide Community Stats

jimothy said:

member since 04 Jun 2004 with 612 posts, unranked, send him a message or view his profile

I'm a big fan of RPTVs, particularly Samsung's LED-based units that have no moving parts (aside from the micro-mirrors of the DLP chip itself) and have a LED light source that should last longer than a plasma set or the backlight of an LCD set. And should it ever go, it's replaceable. When your plasma set ages, it gets dimmer; when it gets too dim, you've got to replace the entire TV.

While it's true that RPTVs are fading in popularity, and are down to two manufactures (Samsung and Mitsubishi), they're not going to be obsolete, as the author claims. Perhaps in a few years, they'll no longer be sold, but that makes an RPTV you buy today no more obsolete down the road than a flat panel bought today will also be down the road.

I just purchased a 61" DLP for under $1,500, and that gives me a top-of-the-line set. At that price, you can get a 50" plasma, plenty big for most people, but it's going to be an entry level set. In LCD, you're mostly looking at under 50". A 60-inch plasma will run you nearly $4,000, and much higher for an LCD set at that size. If you really want to go big, a 72" DLP (with a typical bulb and color wheel) will run you just over $2,000; only pro-athletes and CEOs can afford flat panels at those sizes.

From the front, which is where you're most often going to be looking at a TV, of course, I find DLPs more aesthetically appealing than most flat panels. DLPs have very thin bezels, around 1/2, compared to two-inch borders around most flat panels. In other words, a DLP from the front looks like it's all picture. From the profile, they're not supermodel thin, but they're hardly bulk, and in fact, won't consume more depth on a stand than a flat panel with its base if you decide not to wall mount. Most people, from what I have read, in fact do not wall mount their flat panel TVs.

The biggest legitimate complain against RPTVs, which this article does not mention, is that they've got a smaller viewing angle than plasmas and a good LCD (cheaper LCD panels also have a small viewing angle). But because RPTVs make a big screen so affordable, they offer a large optimal viewing area (your friends don't have to form an arc around a 42" set to get a glimpse of the game).

Finally, DLPs (particular LED based) consume much less power than a plasma, nor do they suffer plasma's glare problem. So, while RPTVs might have a stigma attached to them, my recommendation is to not write them off, but instead follow the other recommendations presented in this article, and see if an RPTV might be perfect for you. Get yourself a fantastic picture, a screen size that will wow you and your friends, and keep a serious stack of bills in your wallet.

Quote this post ↓

FlipFriddle said:

member since 18 Dec 2001 with 480 posts, unranked, send him a message or view his profile

Thanks for the helpful article. My CRT started making some funny noises so I might need this info earlier than I thought. One comment though. I watch a lot of content that is NOT hi-def (local cable news, old re-runs, etc.), and EVERY flat panel TV I have seen that is not displaying HD content looks worse than my 10 year old tube tv. It looks like crap YouTube quality; lots of compression artifacts, smearing, poor gradients, etc. I can't justify paying double to triple what my CRT cost for worse quality. Does anyone know if this issue will be cured when the cable/satellite providers switch to all digital in February?

Quote this post ↓

jimothy said:

member since 04 Jun 2004 with 612 posts, unranked, send him a message or view his profile

I've also got to take issue with the advice on 1080p. Even on a very large screen, like the 61" DLP I mention, you have to sit very close to discern a difference between 720p and 1080p; around seven feet for that 61" screen, much closer for the 46 inch screen the author mentions. 1080p really just begins to at screen sizes above 50" (unless it's an LCD that you're going to also use as a computer monitor). So, if you're looking at a good deal on a 720p plasma or LCD, you may want to go for it, despite what the author advised.

The eye's ability to discern resolution at various distances, and its relevance to HDTVs, is well documented. A little Googling will reveal much, and show that for most popular screen sizes and viewing distances, 720p is adequate. Also, note that you won't find ANY 1080i displays today; the only ones ever in existence were CRT sets (direct view or CRT RPTV), and no CRT HDTVs are sold today.

Quote this post ↓

derpassante said:

member since 23 Aug 2007 with 15 posts, unranked, send him a message or view his profile

Don't forget energy use. Plasma's use more current than LCDs

http://online.wsj.com/public/article/SB119751487989925779.html

Quote this post ↓

deasys said:

member since 08 Apr 2003 with 296 posts, unranked, send him a message or view his profile

1. Source--why no mention of over-the-air (OTA) reception? It's free and provides noticeably better image quality than either satellite or cable.

Otherwise, generally good advice--thanks.

Quote this post ↓

deasys said:

member since 08 Apr 2003 with 296 posts, unranked, send him a message or view his profile

jimothy wrote:
I've also got to take issue with the advice on 1080p. Even on a very large screen, like the 61" DLP I mention, you have to sit very close to discern a difference between 720p and 1080p; around seven feet for that 61" screen, much closer for the 46 inch screen the author mentions.

If you sit at the recommended distance, the advice to go with a set that supports higher native resolution is good.

The idea of modern HDTV is to reproduce in the home a true theatre experience. To get that, for a given HDTV's size and resolution you'll need to sit at the appropriate distance from the screen.

http://myhometheater.homestead.com/viewingdistancecalculator.html

Quote this post ↓

A guest said: (hide)

There's no need to spend even $25 on HDMI cables from Apple. Monoprice.com sells HDMI cables of excellent quality for under $10... often under $5. Don't let a salesman sell you on Monster Cables, whatever you do... unless you're doing a long 25' run, inexpensive cables transmit 1's and 0's just as effectively as expensive cables. There is ZERO difference in the digital image sent over a $3.00 6' HDMI cable from Monoprice as the $50.00 cable from Best Buy with the fancy logos on the package.

Quote this post ↓

A guest said: (hide)

Great article. Wish I had it a month ago when we went shopping for a new HDTV.

One thing the article didn't mention is that the salesman (ours did) may try to sell you needed extras, such as surge suppressor (TV warantee does not cover surge damage) and a cleaning kit. Both are very expensive of course. I bought a similar surge suppressor as I have for my computer equipment at a fraction of the cost. Wiping the TV with lint-free cloth is also a lot cheaper.

Quote this post ↓

jimothy said:

member since 04 Jun 2004 with 612 posts, unranked, send him a message or view his profile

deasys wrote:

The idea of modern HDTV is to reproduce in the home a true theatre experience. To get that, for a given HDTV's size and resolution you'll need to sit at the appropriate distance from the screen.

http://myhometheater.homestead.com/viewingdistancecalculator.html

Thanks for the link. I've seen other calculators, but this is the most detailed. According to this, I should sit 6.8 feet from my 61" screen, and that with 20/20 vision, the max distance to resolve 1080(p) resolution is 8 feet.

I actually view from about 10 feet away; I guess I should have gone for the bigger 67" screen, but even then, the recommended distance is 7.5'. I'd require a 90" screen for 10 feet away, and that's just a wee bit out of my budget.

Still, what this shows is that people should look at a bigger screen than they'd imagine, making DLPs even more attractive, as they make bigger screen sizes affordable for mere mortals.

Quote this post ↓

j.martellaro said:

member since 07 Dec 2006 with 97 posts, TMO Staff, send him a message or view his profile

Some comments:

1. I did mention OTA in the accompanying details article -- because it's limited to local stations.

2. Plasma HDTV energy usage is coming way down in the 2008/2009 models, according to the Panasonic people.

3. I discussed the sitting distance in last year's marathon six part series.

http://www.ipodobserver.com/story/33621

- J.M.

Quote this post ↓

A guest said: (hide)

What "jimothy" says and:

You need to do some serious research on DLP/Projection TV?s. They are not the soon to be obsolete animals you claim. There are new LED (11 year at least life span with a 20,000:1 Contrast) and Laser models that have and will revolutionize DLP and the industry. At least I can replace the bulb for $99 and have my TV back and not have to replace the whole thing what in - LCD/Plasma 3-4 years? And DLP?s are not as unsightly as you make them sound, I prefer the elegant Piano Black Slim Line look of my 50" Samsung 50A650 (the survivor of a purchase of one of each 50" DLP, LCD & Plasma) to any LCD/Plasma's that are currently available. While the crystal clear if not better picture will beat LCD and Plasma?s with the problems that they have for a long time to come. AND the larger the better. This can?t be said for LCD. How big can an LCD be before the pixels become connect the dot wallpaper or just how big can they be? Have they gotten the glass thing worked out yet for both LCD and Plasma?s? And no 120 Hz worries here. Local OTA broadcasts are amazing!!! As are SD broadcasts and being my 4th computer monitor that the others don't do well with. So basically I can watch anything in any format or quality in near to complete perfection. Oh . . . and having 3700 watts of 7.1 Surround Sound doesn't hurt either.

Quote this post ↓

A guest said: (hide)

What "jimothy" says and:

You need to do some serious research on DLP/Projection TV?s. They are not the soon to be obsolete animals you claim. There are new LED (11 year at least life span with a 20,000:1 Contrast) and Laser models that have and will revolutionize DLP and the industry. At least I can replace the bulb for $99 and have my TV back and not have to replace the whole thing what in - LCD/Plasma 3-4 years? And DLP?s are not as unsightly as you make them sound, I prefer the elegant Piano Black Slim Line look of my 50" Samsung 50A650 (the survivor of a purchase of one of each 50" DLP, LCD & Plasma) to any LCD/Plasma's that are currently available. While the crystal clear if not better picture will beat LCD and Plasma?s with the problems that they have for a long time to come. AND the larger the better. This can?t be said for LCD. How big can an LCD be before the pixels become connect the dot wallpaper or just how big can they be? Have they gotten the glass thing worked out yet for both LCD and Plasma?s? And no 120 Hz worries here. Local OTA broadcasts are amazing!!! As are SD broadcasts and being my 4th computer monitor that the others don't do well with. So basically I can watch anything in any format or quality in near to complete perfection. Oh . . . and having 3700 watts of 7.1 Surround Sound doesn't hurt either.

Quote this post ↓

Post Your Comments

  Remember Me

Not a member? Register now. You can post comments without logging in, but they'll show up as a "guest" post.


Please enter the word exactly as you see it in the image above. Registered users aren't prompted for this. Having trouble reading the image get a new one.