Support Our Site
Get Better Gear!
- Notability For iPad: Much More Than A Note Taking App from Ginger Labs, Inc, US$0.99
- Scosche’s RH656m Headphones With Microphone Are Wonderful from Scosche, US$129.99
- IPEVO’s Typi Folio Case & Keyboard for iPad is First-rate from IPEVO, US$79.99
- Scosche’s boomSTREAM BT Speaker: Features & Compromises from Scosche, US$99.95
- FX Photo Studio HD: iPad Painting of Effects Made Easy from MacPhun LLC, US1.99
Top 5 Free Apps
iTunes New Music Releases
Top 5 Paid Apps
Discover New Music
- Death Cab for Cutie
With the introduction of Plans, Death Cab for Cutie became a new addition to many user's Artist list after the single "Soul Meets Body" became a hit on iTunes. Offering a fresh alternativ
- Brother Love
- Killer grooves, catchy riffs, edgy vocals with oh-so-just-right layered harmonies, and a drive that will move even YOU out of your chair, Brother Love's initial release is what rock and roll should be
The Wall (Deluxe Packaging Digitally Remastered)
- Pink Floyd
- Okay, someone had to say it, and though others on the iPO staff are more qualified to review this album, I decided the time was now. This is the quintessential concept album. Though others came before
- Depeche Mode
Oddly enough, Playing The Angel is a return to form for Depeche Mode, even though it may well be argued that they never truly deviated from their roots in their more recent offerings. In the
- World Party
Reader Specials
Visit Deals On The Web for the best deals on all consumer electronics, iPods, and more!
Editorial
An Apple Venture into DVRs Would be Ill-Advised
Wednesday, March 12th, 2008 at 4:00 PM - by John Martellaro
Several sites on Thursday mentioned that Apple has filed a patent on a system that involves a DVR and a remote control device. While Apple can be expected to do its homework on conflicting patents, there are several reasons why adding to DVR to the Apple TV, even with an SSD, would be a bad idea.
If there are people more protective of DVR technology than those who hold IP and patents on DVRs, they are rare. Recently, EchoStar felt the full wrath of TiVo who stated that EchoStar has failed to comply with hefty court award after TiVo claimed their patents were violated. According to TVPredictions on Tuesday, EchoStar now owes TiVo close to US$100M. News of the appeals court verdict sent TiVo stock soaring when it was announced in January.
There are many questions associated an Apple DVR. The Apple TV was roundly criticized when it was first introduced for not having a DVR feature. Apple is a high technology company that certainly could have included this feature if it thought it could deal with existing patents and if such a feature could be an important part of Apples business model. Apple did not.
Next, while TiVo remains a rather small company and depends on agreements with cable and satellite companies to keep it afloat, those very same companies have swooped in and built their own DVRs. Penetration in the U.S. with any kind of DVR is fairly high. Traditional carriers perceive the DVR as an important tool to both satisfy their customers, with that 30-sec skip button, as well as the offsetting ability to provide paid services such as VOD. The gateway to that coaxial cable is controlled very well by carriers despite anemic federal laws.
Given that CableCards have been successfully suppressed by the carriers and that not many Apple customers will be able to see the benefit of two DVRs, battling for interfacing and operational use, I dont see the benefit to Apple.
It could be that Steve Jobs sees the ancient TiVo + HDTV metaphor and software as a ripe business model for Apple exploitation, much as Apple disrupted the mobile phone ecosystem. So Apple filed the patent expecting that, someday, they might decide to jump in and disrupt that market as well. Especially if something changes radically in the technology to their benefit. Apple could buy TiVo, but the idea has been dismissed because Apple doesnt buy companies that are losing money. However, the patent portfolio combined with new, disruptive technologies could be worth it in this case.
Right now, the home HDTV big stakes market is held by some heavyweights who hold the keys, and it wont be very easy for Apple to jump in here. Moreover, Apple is a company that seems to attract lawsuits. Jumping into the DVR business at a late stage, risking lawsuits and the wrath of Hollywood and the carriers just doesnt make sense. It would be too much of a distraction.
I think the Apple TV is a good complement to a current home theater that already has the key components supplied by the satellite or cable carrier. If Apple wanted to get into the DVR business, it would have a long time ago.
Recent Headlines
- Reading, Writing, & Saving the World
- Free Retro Gaming for iOS - Activision’s Kaboom!
- Apple Adds Chomp Bits to iOS 6 App Store Discovery
- Notability For iPad: Much More Than A Note Taking App
- Scosche’s RH656m Headphones With Microphone Are Wonderful
- Tim Cook & Larry Page Reportedly Discuss Patents
- Analysis: Amazon Kindle Fire Sold Out, Kindle Fire 2 Pic Leaked
Post Your Comments